She asks a stranger to call 911 and send a police unit to Jess' house.
"billie227" messages Blaire and tells her that Mitch will die if he leaves.
In a moment of panic, Blaire shows her message on the paper: "If you reveal this note, Adam will die." Adam is forced to shoot himself in the face, and the camera reveals his note: "If you reveal this note, Blaire will die." "billie227" then says that the game is still going and asks whether anyone has ever defaced Laura's grave.
"billie227" forces the remaining four classmates to play a game of Never Have I Ever, stating that the loser of the game will die.
All four classmates are forced to reveal largely personal secrets which put their relationships with each other on the rocks: Jess spread a rumor that Blaire had an eating disorder; Blaire crashed Jess' mother's car while drunk; Mitch reported Adam to the police for selling marijuana, which almost got Adam disowned by his father; Mitch also reveals that he kissed Laura behind Blaire's back shortly before her suicide, although she initiated it and he rejected her advances; Jess stole $800 from Adam and Adam himself offered to trade Jess' life for his own.
The five classmates soon learn that Val is dead, presumably from drinking the bleach, and that the police have ruled it as a suicide through the police codes they overhear through Skype.
Ken manages to remove "billie227" from the chat, but "billie227" resurfaces with a camera view from across his room and disconnects his webcam.Shortly after, Blaire and Adam receive messages sent remotely to their printers.Mitch demands that Blaire reveal her note and threatens to leave the call if she does not."billie227" then posts a video of Laura Barns recording a video similar to that of Amanda Todd, a Canadian girl who committed suicide in 2012 after being bullied and sexually blackmailed.Val calls the police to report online abuse, and signs off Skype.Blaire tells Jess not to answer and "billie227" promptly cuts the power to all the lights in Jess's house and disconnects her video feed.